Introduction
In total, around 15,600 men served in the British West Indies Regiment from its formation in the summer of 1915 to its disbandment after the First World War. The largest number, around 10,000, came from Jamaica, but men from other Caribbean colonies played a full part too; about 600 came from British Guiana (now the independent country of Guyana). Guianese men were certainly the first to enlist as indicated by the regimental service numbers they were given. No.1 was H E Somerset. Somerset made a name for himself as the ringleader of a group of men who complained about the appalling conditions the early arrivals experienced at the training camp in Seaford on the south coast of England. His complaints may well have been legitimate but they did not go down well with his officers and Somerset was sent back to Guiana in disgrace. But this article is not about Private Somerset, instead we focus on No.2 (Hubert Answick) and his brother Christopher (No.17), and their brother-in-law John Pessano, No.194.
Hubert Answick (No.2)
Hubert Answick was born in Georgetown, British Guiana on 4th March 1896. His parents were Thomas Answick and Phyllis Brush.[1]Parents: https://www.ancestry.co.uk/search/collections/60901/records/8691716?tid=&pid=&queryId=f9baf52b-5412-46f6-bf3b-7b42f34a2b90&_phsrc=SIF1386&_phstart=successSource We have not yet identified any further information about Thomas or Phyllis. and nothing is currently known about the early years of Hubert’s life.
In 1915 he enlisted in the British West Indies Regiment. With the regimental No.2, he clearly wasted no time in doing so; only Private Somerset has a lower number.
Two men named Answick were among the earliest recruits: Hubert, No.2, and Christopher, No.17. Were they brothers? Sharing a surname they could have been cousins, but research has shown that they were indeed siblings.
The brothers were on board the RMS Danube, which arrived in Plymouth on 5th September 1915 bringing the very first batch of recruits from the Caribbean to join the war effort. Hubert is shown as age 21, but his brother’s name is shown as C A Auswick with the (very) incorrect age of 24. The names of service personnel should not be recorded on passenger lists but the Danube was a Royal Mail ship that regularly ploughed its furrow back and forth across the Atlantic and often carried fare paying passengers. Whoever maintained the lists must have forgotten the stricture about service personnel.[2]RMS Danube passenger list: … Continue reading
Most men’s service records were destroyed during World War Two when a German incendiary bomb hit the building where they were stored. Many records that survived the fire were severely damaged by the water used to douse the flames. Only about thirty per cent survive at all. Known as ‘the burnt records’, they are held by the National Archives, have been digitised and can be viewed online.
Hubert’s Army service record does not survive, so we can only surmise in general terms where he served. The battalion’s war diary is probably the most useful source in this respect.[3]BWIR First Battalion war diary: https://westindiacommittee.org/historyheritageculture/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/War-Diary.pdf It is likely that he trained at Seaford in Sussex and was on board HMT Marathon on 20th January 1916 when she left Plymouth bound for Alexandria. Once in Egypt he probably spent several months training in the desert to the west of the Suez Canal. It would appear from subsequent records that he was among one of the two contingents of men who were sent in July or November 1916 to serve in the Mesopotamia campaign (modern-day Iraq).

Conditions in Mesopotamia were punishing, and many men succumbed to illness or disease. In November 1918, Hubert was hospitalised with influenza.[5]https://search.findmypast.co.uk/record?id=S2%2FGBM%2FMH106%2FMH106-1208%2F0005&parentid=GBM%2FMH106%2FP2%2F904691 He survived, but many did not.
If we know little of Hubert’s time in the Army, we learn more about his life after the War. At the time of the 1921 census, he was still on active service. The return shows him as a corporal in the Royal Artillery Signals Corps, stationed at No.23 British Stationary Hospital, Baghdad, in Mesopotamia.[6]1921 census, Mesopotamia: … Continue reading
When he was demobilised at Aldershot, instead of returning to his home in British Guiana, he chose to emigrate to the United States and, on 4th August 1922, he boarded the SS Kroonland at Southampton.[7]The SS Kroonland: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VTTPapGMqzw The passenger list for this voyage survives. Although many of the names are indecipherable, Hubert’s can be found among the passengers who embarked at Southampton.[8] … Continue reading He joined a large number of Polish and Hungarian passengers (many of whom were evidently Jewish) who had boarded a few days earlier at Antwerp. Hubert arrived in New York on 13th. He was expecting to be met by his sister Mrs Francis Hall.
On 1st January 1925 he completed the paperwork to become a US citizen and on this form he is described as: colour, black; complexion, dark; eyes, brown; height 6 feet 0 inches. His address was 2550 Seventh Avenue, New York, where he was living with his wife, Rosie. He gave his occupation as chauffeur/mechanic. He and Rosie had married in March 1924; she was from Florida. Later in the application process, the birth of a daughter, Nellie, on 9th June 1927, is recorded. The application was witnessed by his brother, Christopher.[9]https://www.ancestry.co.uk/imageviewer/collections/2280/images/31301_168171-00082?usePUB=true&_phsrc=SIF1444&_phstart=successSource&pId=4043878
On 1st October 1931, he formally became a US citizen.

His address, in the heart of Harlem, was only a few blocks away from the famous Cotton Club but, even if Hubert had any interest in seeing the famous acts performing there, he would have been unable to do so – the club enforced a strict ‘whites only’ policy for its audience. He may have been living in ‘the land of the free’, but his freedom did not extend to seeing the likes of Duke Ellington, Count Basie or Louis Armstrong in their prime performing a stone’s throw from where he lived.
With people from so many backgrounds, New York was a volatile place and tensions sometimes bubbled to the surface. There were significant ‘race’ riots in Harlem 19th to 20th March 1935 in which three people died and there was widespread damage to property. The riots on 1st to 2nd August 1943 were more serious, there were six deaths and over a thousand people were injured or arrested.

In spite of the racism and the barriers, this must have been an incredibly exciting time to live in New York. The Chrysler building was completed in 1930 and the Empire State Building the following year. Hubert would have witnessed all this, a far cry indeed from colonial British Guiana!

Sometimes, perhaps it was a little too exciting! On 28th July 1944, in dense fog, a US Air Force aircraft collided with the Empire State Building causing extensive damage to several upper floors. Fourteen people died in the accident. Every New Yorker would have been shocked by the tragedy, but Hubert’s 7th Avenue address was several miles north of the scene and, although perhaps he would have been able to see the plume of smoke from the burning building from his apartment, he would not have been in any danger.
New Yorkers did not hang about and the building was mostly reopened for business within four days!
Hubert married Mattie/Hattie Williams in Manhattan, New York on 16th December 1936.[11]Marriage to Hattie Williams: https://www.findmypast.co.uk/transcript?id=FS%2FMAR%2F35987289%2F1&tab=this What became of his first wife, Rosie, is not known.
In 1942, now age 46, he was drafted for service in the US Navy in World War 2. Hattie Answick (née Williams) of 2262 Seventh Avenue was named as his next of kin.[12]World War Two, US Navy draft card: … Continue reading
It seems he married for a third time on 23rd September 1946; his bride was Della Williams. Again, we do not know what became of Hattie.[13]Third marriage: … Continue reading
At the time of the 1950 census, now aged 54, Hubert is working as a chauffeur. There is no sign of a Mrs Answick, although he is now sharing his apartment with Elizabeth Barksdale, a 33-year-old lodger and her three children, Harold (age 16), Frederick (15) and Audrey (10).[14]1950 census: https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3QHK-SQHW-9YHT?view=index&personArk=%2Fark%3A%2F61903%2F1%3A1%3A6XY9-N4D3&action=view&cc=4464515&lang=en This wasn’t the first time Hubert had taken in lodgers, at the time of the 1930 census he and his wife, Rosie, had three lodgers. Indeed, it seems to have been standard practice in the community as many of their neighbours also had lodgers. No doubt it helped Hubert pay the $80 a month rent. In 1940 the census shows him sharing his apartment with four lodgers, one of whom, Joshua Estwick, had been born in British Guiana. Hubert’s occupation is now shown as ‘porter’ and that week he had worked 54 hours at a retail candy store. His annual income is shown as $520 (roughly $12,500 at today’s prices). This doesn’t sound a lot but it still made him better paid than most of his neighbours – although a clergyman in the same block had earnings of $700. Joshua Estwick worked 88 hours that week and recorded an annual income of $350.[15]1940 census: … Continue reading New York census returns really do contain a wealth of fascinating detail!
On 4th October 1951, once again a chauffeur and still living on 7th Avenue, he registered to vote and declared his allegiance as being a Democrat.
Hubert made more than one return visit to British Guiana. On 13th September 1951 he was on Pan American Airlines flight 206-11, accompanied by Lucille and Barbara Answick, when it landed at New York from Georgetown.[16] … Continue reading We have found no further trace of Lucille or Barbara and so do not know how they were related to Hubert. The contrast between the British colony and his home in New York must have been amazing.

In August 1955 he was travelling again, apparently alone this time. On 8th August Pan Am 257/171/08 landed at Frederikstead in the British Virgin Islands. Hubert was on board but it was probably a fleeting stop, his final destination is shown as Georgetown, British Guiana. It seems the return journey was via Puerto Rico where he landed on 2nd September 1955 en route for New York. [17] … Continue reading
We have traced no further flights for Hubert but, given that his name appeared in voter registration records until at least 1956, and that he was still listed in the Manhattan telephone directory in 1960, he clearly lived in Manhattan for several more years.[18]1960 telephone directory: … Continue reading
No record of his death has yet been traced.
Christopher Adolphus Augustus Answick (No.17)
Christopher Answick was born on 22nd August 1900 in Georgetown, British Guiana. His parents were Thomas Answick and Phyllis Brush. Nothing is known of Christopher’s early life.
Like Hubert, his name appears on the passenger list of the RMS Danube. when she arrived in Plymouth on 5th September 1915. It been slightly mis-transcribed as Auswick, but it is clearly him. His age, however, is completely wrong. It is shown as 24 but, in fact, it seems likely that he celebrated his 15th birthday on the journey to England. Clearly he must have been very keen to enlist and accompany his brother to England, equally clearly, the recruiting authorities in Guiana were none too diligent in checking the age of recruits.
Nothing is known of Christopher’s war time service but, after the War he apparently returned to British Guiana where he married and had a daughter before emigrating to the United States where he was reunited with his brother. He and his wife and daughter reached New York via Trinidad, from whence they sailed on the SS Vestris on 15th November 1923, arriving in New York on 25th.[19] https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:JN8T-26P?lang=en The Vestris sank with catastrophic loss of life on 12th November 1928.
He travelled with his wife, Ada Alitia[20]We learn that Ada’s middle name was Alitia from her own application for citizenship … Continue reading (born 14th November 1904), and daughter Cornelia (born 31st March 1922 in British Guiana).[21]https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3Q9M-C9RB-DSHS-G?view=index&personArk=%2Fark%3A%2F61903%2F1%3A1%3AJN8T-26P&action=view&cc=1368704&lang=en His calling or occupation is given as ‘artificer’ which suggests he had had a specialised role as a mechanic or technician in the Army. His father is shown as Thomas Answick of 64 Howes Street, Georgetown, which proves that he and Hubert were brothers.
Like his brother before him, Christopher applied for US citizenship. From the application he signed on 11th February 1927 we learn that he was black, had black hair and brown eyes and was 5 feet 10 inches tall. He was living at 501 West 172nd Street with Ada, and worked as a superintendent and elevator operator.[22]https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3QS7-89HF-H91S?view=index&personArk=%2Fark%3A%2F61903%2F1%3A1%3AZX56-LC3Z&action=view&cc=2060123&lang=en . There were many forms to fill in before you could become a citizen and, another one dated 27th June 1929, confirms what we already know about Christopher and his small family, although three given names, Christopher Adolphus Augustus, are now included. This form was witnessed by his sister-in-law, Rosie Answick.[23]https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3QS7-99HF-HS4X?view=index&personArk=%2Fark%3A%2F61903%2F1%3A1%3AZX5J-993Z&action=view&cc=2060123&lang=en
At the time of 1he 1940 census he is still living with Ada and Cornelia, eighteen now, and Cyril Pestano is also with them (we will come back to Cyril) . Christopher worked long hours as the supervisor of an apartment building, but with an annual income of $840 was relatively well paid. Cyril earnt the same amount as an elevator operator. The $70 monthly rent on the apartment gobbled up most of Christopher’s income but they were doing OK and better than many. The birth places of those who also lived in the same area – Turkey, Greece, Germany, Italy, China, England and Scotland – show what a melting pot New York was.[24] https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3QS7-89MB-9X4R?view=index&personArk=%2Fark%3A%2F61903%2F1%3A1%3AKQGD-HZD&action=view&cc=2000219&lang=en
On 15th February 1942, Christopher was drafted for service in World War Two, Ada is his next of kin.

At the time of the 1950 census, Christopher and Ada are still together but Cornelia is no longer with them and Cyril Pestano has also moved on.[26]https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3QHN-PQHW-9TT5?view=index&personArk=%2Fark%3A%2F61903%2F1%3A1%3A6XPP-F1JS&action=view&cc=4464515&lang=en{[(|fnote_stt|)]}
There no signs of Christopher having travelled, and he seems to have settled for just the one wife. Snapshots like this can obviously not tell the whole story of someone’s life, but one gets the impression that Christopher led a more settled existence than his brother.
John Pestano (No.194)
John Pestano was another man who was on the RMS Danube when she docked at Plymouth on 5th September 1915. His regimental number was No.194.
John was born in British Guiana in about 1888.[27]https://www.findmypast.co.uk/transcript?id=GBM%2FLIVES%2F3485984&tab=this
He is a man whose Army file did survive the German incendiary bomb in 1940 and so we know rather more about his Army service than the Answick brothers. Pestano was, in fact, their brother-in-law.
His file does not make happy reading.
He enlisted on 18th August 1915 and, to begin with, his Army career seems to have been unremarkable. After arriving at Plymouth, he and his fellow recruits made the journey across southern England by train to the recently established training camp in Seaford. Conditions at the camp were appalling. The hastily knocked together huts offered little protection from the English weather which was particularly bad that autumn.
In a case of mistaken identity, on 20th October 1915, the battalion’s war diary reported the death of Private Pessano (presumably Pestano, as there was no Private Pessano in Seaford at the time) in hospital at Seaford. In fact it was Private David Primo who died (of pneumonia) on that date, the first of nineteen BWIR men to die while training at Seaford.
Reports of his death having been ‘greatly exaggerated’ (as Mark Twain is reported to have said after reading his own obituary), John Pestano travelled by train back to Plymouth where he boarded HMT Marathon on the morning of Friday 21st January 1916. The battalion diary records the ship’s journey past Gibraltar and mentions a brief stop at Valetta, Malta, before docking at Alexandria at 5 p.m. on Friday 4th February. Typically business like, the diary makes no mention of the excitement the men must have felt as they disembarked.
Within days of his arrival, John Pestano’s service took an unexpected and shocking turn.
He eventually left Egypt on 6th June 1916 and returned to England. From 19th June to 7th September he was treated in Bethnal Green military hospital for deafness. The report on his file gives the cause of his hearing loss:
was caused by being sandbagged by Australians in Egypt February 19th.
No reason is given for what was described as an ‘attack’ by Australian soldiers, but it is not at all unreasonable to suppose that it was racially motivated. The description ‘sandbagging’ suggests a violent assault, presumably to the head given the effect on his hearing. The hostility of Australian (and South African) troops to soldiers of colour has been well documented; that the casual reference to John Pestano being ‘sandbagged’ passes without comment suggests this was not an unknown phenomenon to whoever wrote the report.
Back in England, he was transferred to the Army Service Corps, given the No. M/271779, and no doubt put on light duties at a base camp, probably at Grove Park in London. He was discharged from the Army as no longer fit for active service in June 1917 and awarded a payment of £13 15 shillings, £12 10 shillings of which was apparently in respect of his ‘very slight’ disablement.[28]https://search.findmypast.co.uk/record?id=gbm%2fwo363-4%2f007272015%2f01163&parentid=gbm%2fwo363-4%2f7272015%2f91%2f1158 In addition to the British War Medal and the Victory Medal, he was awarded the Silver War Badge to reflect the fact he had left the service for medical reasons.
On 22nd June 1917 John Pestano, a ‘motor driver’, boarded the SS Santille at London for the return journey to Georgetown.[29] … Continue reading His war was over and he could return home to see his son.
Postscript
Establishing with any certainty what became of John Pestano after his return to Guiana has proved problematic. However we do know that he already had a son there. On the Army file, the son’s name is shown as John [Lewis?], born 12th November 1913. That may or may not be correct but there was certainly a son called Cyril.
Cyril travelled to New York on the SS Vestris with his uncle, Chistopher Ainswick (the name Ainswick has been crossed through and replaced with Pestano), in 1923. Cyril was age 11.[30]Passenger list for the SS Vestris : https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:JN8T-26P?lang=en Thomas Answick is shown as his grandfather. We do not know why Cyril was travelling with his uncle and aunt or what had become of his father, but it transpires that his mother was already living in New York. Cyril Pestano’s life in the USA is a different story which we will not cover here.
Finally, there is strong evidence to suggest that John Pestano had made two attempts to emigrate to the United States before his enlistment in the BWIR. A john Pestano, very probably ‘our’ man, arrived in New York on 21st May 1915 as a stowaway on the SS Zulie. After being briefly hospitalised, he was deported.[31]John Pestano arrives in New York as a stowaway in … Continue reading
This may not have been his first attempt to get to New York as a John Pestano had arrived on 2nd April 1915, also as a stowaway![32]April 1915 arrival in New York: … Continue reading
It seems there is still a lot to be discovered about John Pestano!
References